Recent Posts

There Are a Lot of Arguments Against the Pirates, Stop Picking the Bad Ones

Michael Ryan’s firing this week is the latest tempest in a teapot

We have less than a month of TPOP left, and that means I feel very little need to pull any punches. This week I was planning to write about the absurdity of using public education dollars to fund high school football and soccer given the sports’ links to CTE and, at least with the American football, the culture it creates leading to preventable youth deaths. You may still get that piece. Instead, I’ll do something even more controversial as I’ll defend the Pittsburgh Pirates front offense from pointless, baseless criticism, though I will get some jabs in as well.

Caveat before I move on. I’m not interested in defending the front office from all criticism. They’ve earned more than their fair share. The major league team is a directionless mess at the moment. The organizational philosophies are failing. The ones that have succeeded have been copied and improved upon by other organizations. Those philosophies haven’t been replaced with anything cutting edge. Teams with tight finances need to stay ahead of the game, because being ahead of the game comes cheaper. Twelve years into Neal Huntington’s tenure and I wouldn’t have an issue if everyone were fired.

There are plenty of angles to tear the front office down, but I don’t get why the local media insists on petty takes like calling the firing of Altoona and Bradenton managers Michael Ryan and Wyatt Toregas scapegoating. You could feel the spin coming on social media, the moment the moves were announced. It started as condescension as the news broke and rapidly spiraled into vitriol over the next 24 hours. “How could the Pirates fire a coach who wins in the minors when they can’t win in the majors,” echoed social media., “They should have been fired themselves.”

“They did it over the phone?” cried a great deal of people who didn’t know who Ryan or Toregas were until earlier that day.

Remember 9/4/19 as the day Western and Central Pennsylvania found a new piece of minutia as an excuse with which to pile on the Pirates. The Bucs claim they just decided to move on, and we won’t likely know the real reason for the dismissal. Cory Giger of the Altoona Mirror speculates rigid culture. I’ve seen the word scapegoat used or alluded to without actually saying the word. Without the Pirates actually blaming organizational problems on those two, it’s difficult to call them scapegoats. It’s also difficult to imagine Frank Coonelly falling for such a poor excuse for failure as to blame an upper and mid-level minor league manager for the current struggles.

At the end of the day, minor league wins are almost inconsequential. Player development is the name of the game. I don’t even think minor league fans care about the W’s. What they want are cheap seats, stupid toppings on cheeseburgers, the occasional major league rehab, a great player or two they can say played there, 20,000 mascots, and that sound effect of the windshield breaking when a foul ball clears the roof behind home plate. Here’s an alternative take. The Pirates have someone in mind for the position that they think can better develop players. That’s not to say that they will be better or that the philosophies they’ll be charged with executing are the correct ones. They just might have someone they view as more qualified in mind, wins be damned.

The office may not appreciate Ryan breaking future Hall of Famer Robbie Glendinning, who hasn’t played since August 7th. Maybe, that’s just me though (it’s probably just me).

This might also be just the beginning of bigger changes coming down the road. Rob Biertempfel speculates as much in this headline. His justification is behind a paywall which means I haven’t read it. I do tend to agree with the idea though. Keep in mind, the minor league season is over. Now is the time to fire minor league coaches. Just because they fired Ryan and Toregas doesn’t mean they can’t or won’t fire Farm Director Larry Broadway, VP and Assistant GM Kyle Stark, pitching coach Ray Searage or even Huntington or Clint Hurdle. Those moves will likely be made after the major league season, and I think changes will be made. Maybe not the ones fans want or the ones the organization needs, but I don’t expect this will be the end of the changes they make. Just because these are the only changes they’ve made to date doesn’t mean they’ll be the only changes they make. To the best of my knowledge, organizations can make personnel changes anytime they’d like.

This story isn’t unprecedented. There is a history of criticizing the Pirates organization for stupid things. Hoka Hey being the biggest sensation. If for some reason you don’t know or remember what I’m talking about, Google it. There aren’t many minor trades or player signings that take place that aren’t met with the refrain of “get the parade route planned.” Those individual moves are relatively inconsequential in a vacuum. When you add them up over time, they’re an issue, but no one seems to make that argument. The entire organization got dragged through the mud for how Rene Gayo courted and ultimately got dumped by Miguel Sano’s family. Interestingly, Gayo is one of the few people in the front office to actually be held accountable for his failings. It sucks the Pirates didn’t get Sano, but that story probably got overblown.

Again, I’m not saying that the Pirates are above criticism. They’re not. They deserve the volume of jabs they get at the moment. The content is sometimes the problem. All that I’m asking is that people stop making bad arguments when they criticize the Pirates. There are big things wrong with this franchise. To criticize minutia only detracts and distracts from the real issues. In the big picture who manages AA and A+ probably doesn’t matter much. It’s easier to just look at news bites and over react to them than it is to add something to new to the conversation. Sometimes you just need to look at a story and say “is this really a big deal?”

Steve is a naturalized yinzer hailing originally from just north of Allentown, PA. He came to Pittsburgh to attend Duquesne University and decided to stick around after graduation. Steve is best known for his contributions to Duquesne hoops community as the owner of the Duquesne Dukes forum on Yuku and as the former editor of We Wear the Ring on the Fansided network. He is an avid Pirates fan, home cook and policy nerd. He is the co-founder of the Point of Pittsburgh. Easily irritated by people who misuse the word regress.

7 Comments on There Are a Lot of Arguments Against the Pirates, Stop Picking the Bad Ones

  1. As you point out, wins are not important in the minor leagues, player development is the goal. When, year after year, players arrive at the major league level who can’t or won’t play fundamentally sound baseball, (defense, base running, throwing to the correct base, etc.), it doesn’t take much to justify moving on. I think that Hurdle and Searage are as good as gone, and I hope that the Pirates look outside of the organization for replacements. Internal candidates are infected with the hot mess that currently invades the organization top to bottom.

    • Steve DiMiceli // September 5, 2019 at 8:53 PM // Reply

      Ditto on Hurdle and Searage. I honestly considered a paragraph that I think these moves might portend a major shake up in the coaching staff across all levels of the organization, but I don’t have much to support the idea. Call it a gut feeling at best.

  2. Frankly, I found the Giger article a little provincial and blinkered, and I am as blinkered and provincial as the next guy. The fact that Ryan is respected and beloved in Altoona and hates losing is tangential at best to the business of player development.

    • Steve DiMiceli // September 5, 2019 at 8:55 PM // Reply

      I legit like Giger. I thought he raised some solid points. Overvaluing minor league wins and crafting the bulk of your hot take around it? Not so much.

  3. great news please keep me updated

  4. Steve….stop making sense! That’s not what legit media members do, ya know?

  5. Exactly. People get petty because they are angry with the owner being cheap, which obviously has a major effect on all aspects of the organization. Obviously drafting and development has been terrible for pitchers. That needs changed. We all know that. Also, if Searage cannot or will not make changes in his philosophy, he will have to go. Its been too glaringly obvious that pitchers have been doing better elsewhere (Cole, morton, Glasnow) or not doing enough in PIT (archer, etc)
    Changes will be made because they have to be, but nobody should not understand the real problem is nutting and he needs to change his way of running this business now.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*